Willow says that the player felt good for themselves, ripping her away from the ones she cared about. Willow then turns to you, accusing the player of taking Willow away from her family.
From what Willow reveals is that Pony was a good friend, but adds that he is nothing to Willow now. Willow walks up to Pony, revealing that he was an ex-member, saying "It's a shame that you left us". Willow then appears along with Tigry, Pandy, Kitty, and Baren surrounding you, surprisingly not infected. Pony asks if it's the right place since no one is around. When the screen lights up, you see that you are in a Forest. It ends up with you, Zizzy, and Pony again to meet them. Mimi stays also, so she can continue to fix the radio. Giraffy says that he will need to stay, so that he can harvest as much as he can before winter. Pony hesitates, but then gives in, still not trusting the Settlement. You, the player, agree with Zizzy, remembering when Zizzy and Pony fought an army of infected at the Plant.
If we get into trouble, we know how to get out of it". Pony is surprised and tries to convince Zizzy not to go, but she reassures Pony by saying: "Pony, we know how to handle ourselves out there. Zizzy agrees with Pony but still wants to meet up. Pony replies, that he is being serious about this and won't go. Giraffy starts to doubt Pony, asking if he's making another joke. Mimi is delighted, wanting to meet them but Pony is reluctant. They tell you to meet them at Old Oak, but then you lose the signal. They are looking for any communities to trade with and request to meet up. It eventually works and someone starts to talk claiming to be called Settlement Six. Mimi uses the batteries to restore the Radio mentioned in Chapter 1. You see Mimi and Giraffy next to the radio. After you get the batteries and get out, you and the rest go back to the safe place with the batteries. It starts with you, Zizzy, and Pony in a store searching for batteries. Zizzy afterwards has a plan that they go to the store along with Pony and the Player. Mimi soon informs Zizzy, Pony, and the Player about the old radio they have. Zee, Zuzy, and Georgie are playing tag in the Safe Place, while Giraffy can be seen gardening in the background. As they exit, a white flash ends the flashback and returns you to the events following the end of Book 1. They then have a conversation about how this is just the way things have to be and that they couldn't do anything about it. Then, Player and Doggy walking out of the room, but the player stops and tells Doggy that this doesn’t feel right. Rash reluctantly agrees but warns the player that they haven’t seen the last of them, and the screen fades to black. Rash attempts to take you and Doggy by surprise, but Willow stops him, saying that it isn’t worth it. Once you corner Willow, she explains that she needed the food to feed her family but turns herself in without resisting. The player and Doggy are tasked to arrest Willow and Rash, who have been stealing food and supplies from all around the city. The Player has a flashback to an arrest where Officer Doggy and the player made before the infection at the alleys, which is the opposite of Gallery.